Hey guys i've set up a brainstorm account via bubbl.us. If you follow this link: www.bubbl.us and sign in with these account details:
username: context1
passworld: 12345
Then on the right panel there should be a saved file called something like 'immersive video games list' it will load the brainstorm. It would be great if we could all update this brainstorm with some games that we think have immersive level designs and just some brief points why we think this, so that we have a good list of games to go more indepth with.
Remember be strict, make sure the game has immersive level design.
Heres what the brainstorm is looking like currently:
Tuesday, 8 March 2011
Top 3 immersive level designs
"The feeling of being taken up into the narrative world: when a participant is immersed in an experiance, they are willing to accept the internal logic of the experience, even though this logic deviates from the logic of the real world. This willing of disbeleif feeds a player's ability to imemerse himself in a charater and to take meaningful action through character agency." - Description of immersion by Mateas and Stern, Game Design Reader, page 29.
Introduction
This is a group blog that we are going to use to post short reviews to a variety of different video games, reviewing them in terms of how immersive the level designs are (taking narrative, audio and visual into account - aslong as they backup the core design of the level) Scoring them along the way.
We will then choose the top 3 that we feel are the strongest immersive level designs, and then write more indepth reviews. These top 3 will be included into our playable game presentation that will be created in either unity or source.
The members of our group who will be posting on this blog are:
- Matty O'Connor
- William Gall
- Jack Eaves
Grading Matrix
We will judge each game based on the different areas stated below:
- Believability: In order for a game to be truely immersive the player must, in context, believe that the world that they are in could be real. Factors of this could be how relatable the game is to the player or the level of detail put into the environment.
- Flow: If the game doesn't flow well the player can become annoyed and lose the will to play the game. Examples of bad flow are: not being able to navigate the level without becomming frustrated or having to go back and forth long distances too often for tasks, this can become boring.
- Playtime: This can be seen 2 ways. How much playtime you get from playing the game until its finished or how long the player feels compelled to play the game each session. If the player is fully immersed in a game experiance they won't usually want to stop, meaning a longer play session. Some games have too short playtime and because of this they end far too soon, leaving the player feeling cheated and wanting more (in a negative way).
- Agency: Agency is the feeling of being able to make meaningful actions in a fictional world. For example being able to choose to accept someones help, your decision effects wiehteror not this person joins you and other elements of the narrative revolving around their being part of your group.
Each point will be given a score out of 10. The scores will then be added up to form a total. The 3 with the highest score will be taken further and added to the presentation archive.
Useful Links
Here are some useful links about immersion in video games, might help to give us all a better idea of how to judge the games. Feel free to add to them if you find anything useful, but please write your name next to each thing you edit so that James knows who has done what.
- http://illumin.usc.edu/article.php?articleID=103 - Jack
- http://www.gamasutra.com/view/news/29910 /Analysis_The_Psychology_of_Immersion_in_Video_Games.php - Jack
- The Game Designer reader has some very interesting articles on immersion also. -Jack
DEADLINE : MAY 2011
Biblography
Biblography
- Katie Salen, Eric Zimmerman,"Player and Character." Game Design Reader" 2006, 29-31
- Katie Salen, Eric Zimmerman,"Interaction and Narrative." Game Design Reader" 2006, 648-651
