Now that i am back home in Bristol for the Easter Break i have access to play Uncharted 2 again, so that i can make sure that this review is accurate.
The way that naughty dog have approached the level design is to try to keep the player in control through each situation where possible. For example there is a scene in a skyscraper where you enter a room, confronted by enemy soldiers. However halfway through the fight a helicopter appears at the far end of the room (visibile through windows) and opens fires, blasting away the side of the building and collapsing it in the process. In most games this would be a cutscene however the player has full control ,continuing to fight with the enemies and avoid gun fire from the helicopter whilst the building is falling, the debris and furniture swaying around the room, eventually crashing into another building where a cutscene is triggered. This interactivity with a complex scene keeps you immersed as you are intensly focusing on the various elements happening around you whilst trying to stay alive, however the rather small cutscene triggered directly after this (of the the characters jumping between the two buildings to safety and having a conversation) almost spoils the effort gone into keeping the player in control. Though i feel this isn't critical enough to effect the score of the level overall as this un-playable cutscene isn't anything interesting that the player is missing out on, only a conversation between characters.
Agency: Uncharted 2 gives a sence of agency through the use of puzzles - the player must activly solve puzzles throughout each level, some obvious and some subtle, however these puzzles usually effect the environment and allow the player to continue. For example maneuvuring mirrors to correctly reflect light so that a statue's limbs move to allow the player to climb and reach their goal.
However this form of agency is very linear as the player must solve the puzzles in order to continue and has no choice of routes to take, on the one. I think this still works well for the immersion of the game as it allows the developers to add much more depth and detail to the outcomes of the puzzles. However giving the players more choice of how they could solve each puzzle would make the player feel more strongly that their actions are making a difference in the fictional world, instead of it just being another stepping stone along the way.
6/10
Believability: The narrative of Uncharted 2 revolves around Marco Polo's voyage home from China, with added extras to fill in the gaps. This increases familiarity to the player as it as grounding in 'real world' events. Taking advantage of the PS3 hardware allows the artists to focus on much more attention to detail for the assets and characters, to increase the sence of authenticity of the surroundings. All of these aspects, alongwith the mocap animations and stunning voice acting come together to allow the game to be much more belieavable to the player. 8/10
Flow: Keeping the player in control throughout the majority of the game, as mentioned above, keeps the flow consistant between the major plot points, this is called Dramatic Narrative 'Dramas utilize action rather than description to tell a story' 'the player does not sit above the story, watching as in simulation, but is immersed in the story' (Katie Salen, Eric Zimmerman,"Interaction and Narrative." Game Design Reader" 2006, 648). However there are still cutscene moments that could have also been playable, this would have added the icing on the cake but isn't a major fault as sometimes it is good for the player to be able to sit back and watch a cutscene that introduces a character for example, to make sure that the connection is fully permitted, without allowing the player to wonder off and miss the event. Due to the nature of the game, there can be sections that can interupt the flow whilst you are trying to solve a puzzle, 'Puzzles disrupt enactment, breaking immersion in the action and forcing reflection on the action as a problem to be solved.'(Katie Salen, Eric Zimmerman,"Interaction and Narrative." Game Design Reader" 2006, 648). 6/10
Playtime: I found the game very hard to put down once i started playing it, almost an addiction and an urge to keep playing and finish the game. In terms of session play-time the game scores highly, keeping you involved for hours at a time without becomming bored or disinterested. However because of this, the overall playtime of the game feels shorter, i finished the game in around 2 days with around 12 hours game play time. Which is about average for most current games however i didn't feel dissapointed once i had finished it, as i had with previous current gen games. 8/10